6
Nov
ICANN Agrees to Investigate Domain Snatching Cases
I’ve read quite a lot about domain snatching recently, best summed up in this article by Daily Domainer.
The accusation being made is that domain availability searches are not being kept private and this data is either being sold or somehow obtained by other registration companies.
The usual complaint is that people are carrying out domain research and return some days or hours later to find the domain mysteriously purchased. In some reports this can even happen between the availability lookup and payment screens. As Daily Domainer suggests, an interception used to take days - now it can be completed within minutes.
Last week an associate of mine was bulk-checking 200+ generic typo domains through a software that shall remain unnamed for now. All of the domains were available. But less than 2 minutes later, more than 50 of the domains had been registered by a number of different offshore companies from the Bahamas.There is no way this could be a coincidence. And if you read the more recent comments in the above mentioned article, it’s clearer than ever before that there are severe leaks somewhere that allow domain tasters to compromise your domain searches and steal your domain ideas.
While this is easy enough if you set up your own domain availability tool, these accusations are being leveled at some of the best known Registrars in the industry. The questions people are asking is who is involved and have they sold this information willingly or is their security compromised?
According to the AP Newswire, the Security and Stability Advisory Committee of ICANN have termed the practice “domain name front running” and likened it to a stock broker buying or selling shares ahead of a client’s trade, in anticipation of a movement in price.
Although they have no proven cases they want to stop this this, “perception from evolving to accepted wisdom” and have launched an investigation into the complaints.
Officially they have suggested this phenomenon may be caused by computer viruses, unscrupulous third-party sites or coincidence rather than pointing the finger at Registrars. While it maybe hard for ICANN to prove anything through this investigation, the extra attention may pressure those involved to stop before they are publicly exposed.
If you have information that can be useful to this investigation you are asked to contact ICANN. Details can be found on their PDF advisory. They have also called for the domaining community to suggest measures that could restrict or stop this practice. Personally I would force any registrar, registration agent or domain tool that sells or stores user lookup data to disclose this in their privacy policy, that would be a start.
November 8th, 2007 at 6:14 pm
I hope it’s not one of the culprits, but I’m a big fan of Instant Domain Search, which puts AJAX to good use, determining availability of partial names as you type. I originally switched out of paranoia after a couple of names conveniently went off the market within 2 weeks of searches on Network Solutions. Of course, I can’t prove anything, but it just makes sense: these searches are a valuable commodity, and sooner or later someone is going to sell them.
November 9th, 2007 at 3:23 pm
Hi Dr. Pete, thanks for stopping by. Yes there are some great domain research tools available but there must be a temptation to sell this data. I don’t think there is anything ICANN can do to stop them doing this, there’s no restrictions on using the open WHOIS APIs. The only way I can see progress being made is user pressure for disclosure in their privacy statements.
March 4th, 2008 at 11:50 am
I too believe this to be true. I have done searches only to find them purchased within minutes. I’m in Canada and called the CBC in Toronto and tried to explain to them about this and wanted them to do a story. Problem was, they at the CBC didn’t even know what the Internet is ! I now only with credit card in hand and ready to hit the purchase button so the transaction will go thru right away will I purchase a domain. I never type in a domain name unless I can close the deal right away.